A heavy crossbow hits for 1d10 piercing damage, while a hand crossbow deals 1d6. The larger die is tempting, but range, weapon proficiency, and the hands needed to fire all shape the decision. This comparison uses the 2024 fifth-edition D&D rules for crossbows; the older 2014 rules have a different version of the Crossbow Expert feat.
Compare the three weapons
The 2024 equipment table gives each model a normal and a long range, measured in feet. The first number is normal range; beyond it and up to the second number, the attack roll has disadvantage. You cannot attack beyond the long range.
| Weapon | Damage | Range | Proficiency category | Hands |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Hand crossbow | 1d6 piercing | 30/120 | Martial | One |
| Light crossbow | 1d8 piercing | 80/320 | Simple | Two |
| Heavy crossbow | 1d10 piercing | 100/400 | Martial | Two |
With a hand crossbow, 5e characters can hold another object in the other hand, but loading it normally requires that hand to be free. Its short normal range favors a character comfortable working close to the action. It also has the Light property, which can matter when combining attacks with another Light weapon under the applicable rules.
The light model is a practical ranged choice for a character proficient with simple weapons who wants to stay back. A wizard, for example, can use it as a weapon attack without spending a spell slot. It takes both hands to attack, so the character must account for any other equipment being held.
With a heavy crossbow, 5e characters gain the largest damage die and longest normal range of the three. A martial weapon user guarding an exposed approach can make good use of that reach. Its Heavy property also imposes disadvantage on attack rolls with this ranged weapon if the wielder’s Dexterity is below 13. Proficiency matters: without it, you do not add your proficiency bonus to attack rolls with the weapon.
Loading and ammunition are separate
All three crossbows have Loading. Under the base rule, when an action, bonus action, or reaction is used to fire a Loading weapon, it can fire only one piece of ammunition as part of that action, even if the character could normally make several attacks. A fighter’s Extra Attack alone therefore does not permit two shots from the same crossbow in one Attack action.
Each shot also consumes a bolt. Drawing ammunition is part of the attack; loading a one-handed weapon normally needs a free hand. After a fight, the 2024 rules allow you to spend one minute recovering half the ammunition you used, rounded down. Keep track of bolts on long trips where resupply matters.
With any crossbow, 5e players should also consider proximity. A ranged attack roll normally has disadvantage if an enemy is within 5 feet, can see the attacker, and doesn’t have the incapacitated condition. A short-range weapon does not automatically remove that penalty.
What Crossbow Expert changes
The 2024 Crossbow Expert feat has level and Dexterity prerequisites. It lets you ignore Loading for these three weapons and load them while holding them even without a free hand. A character with Extra Attack and sufficient bolts can therefore fire the same crossbow more than once with the Attack action. The feat also removes the stated close-enemy disadvantage for crossbow attacks.
The feat has a separate benefit for the extra attack from the Light property. Follow that property’s conditions, including the need for a different Light weapon for the additional attack; the feat does not turn one hand crossbow into a free bonus-action shot on its own.
Choose for your character
To choose a crossbow, 5e players can start with proficiency and likely distance. Pick the light crossbow for simple-weapon access and useful reach, the heavy model for a proficient ranged fighter with enough Dexterity, or the hand model for a compact one-handed weapon. If you expect to make repeated shots with Extra Attack, weigh the feat against your other character choices and keep enough bolts ready.





